Autistic vs With Autism

By
Cross posted at Say Anything: Reader blogs.

Should we refer to an individual as "autistic" or "a person with autism"? Some people are very diligent about drawing a distinction between the two and making a point of saying that they will only use one. Usually they choose "person with autism". I didn't really care about the distinction until I started working on this post.

I've leaned more towards "autistic" because it is far less cumbersome to say and write. But many would argue that merely saying "autistic" de-emphasizes the personhood of the autistic individual while "person with autism" recognises that the individual is "a person first". I disagree with that mode of thinking.

I've cooked up this niffty little graphic over here to help me make my point (no wise cracks about my graphics skills please). What is it? It's a cup. What kind of cup? It's a red cup. Does the fact that it's red make it any less of a cup? Not to my mind so why bother with saying something like "a cup that happens to be red" (equivalent to "a person with autism") instead of just "a red cup" (equivalent to "autistic")?

My analogy breaks down a bit because red-ness does not imply cup-ness. However, personhood is implied in the term "autistic." It is a descriptor that is only appropriate for people while red can appropriately describe a multitude of things. "Person with autism" suggests, even though the people using the term would (I hope) deny believing such a thing, that autism can exist without personhood. That's not something that I want to imply.

In any case, I think a more important distinction to make in how we use language in discussing autism is to recognise that people are autistic for life. Autism is not a childhood something that will fade away with time. The autistic kids that we worry about today will grow up (with that that entails) to be autistic adults each one as different from the other as snowflakes. They will still need our love, support, and compassion then. There are autistic adults today who need it now.

Comments

  1. CasdokApril 03, 2008 1:27 PM

    I did a poll a few months ago asking parents and autistic people which they prefer. The parents said 'with autism' and the autistic people preferd autistic.

    ReplyDelete
  2. SamApril 03, 2008 7:32 PM

    I'm not surprised. I suppose many a parent would tend to think of autism as something separate in their child while the autistic adult would recognise it as a component of their being.

    ReplyDelete
  3. UnknownApril 08, 2008 1:23 AM

    The most eloquent argument I know of for "autistic person" rather than "person with autism" was written several years ago by Jim Sinclair, cofounder of Autism Network International, the autistic self-advocacy organization that produces the annual Autreat conference/retreat.

    I'm both a parent and an adult on the autism spectrum. I *greatly* prefer "autistic person", for the same reasons Jim puts forth.

    I wrote about the subject too, in the appendices of a paper I contributed to Autism and Representation, an academic conference held at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland in October 2005, examining the way autism and autistic people are represented in literature, film, and popular culture. There are a few more sources worth reading, that I mentioned in the paper, among them Jean Kearns Miller's wonderful anthology of writings by women on the spectrum, Women From Another Planet: Our Lives in the Universe of Autism.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Rise Up In The Darkness

By
Image
The teenager who joked with me over physics and algebra homework tonight was 6 months old the morning of September 11, 2001. He spent that day like many other 6 month olds spend their days, exploring his world and being saved from his own curiosity by mom. That morning after I got tired of hauling him back from the edge of the bed he was intent on crawling over I took him downstairs to safer level terrain. I turned on the television to check the news like I did every morning back then. At first I was horrified by what I saw. One smoldering tower. Not long after, while all the reporters and newscasters were struggling to make sense of what they were seeing, one plane, another tower, and I was pissed. At that point I understood what was happening. Why did people think, and still think, that kind of wretchedness served their cause? I didn't care what the cause was. These were arrogant fools. But the news kept coming about just how wretched humanity had been to itself that day. The
Read more

Treating autism as traumatic brain injury

By
I've been doing research into autism, dyspraxia, how the normal brain works, and how an autistic/dyspraxic brain works (or doesn't work). Traumatic injury to different parts of the brain can cause the same problems suffered by autistic and dyspraxic children. Compare this list of the functions of different parts of the brain and the problems caused by injuries to those areas with these descriptions of dyspraxia and autism. What is Developmental Dyspraxia? Developmental dyspraxia is a disorder characterized by an impairment in the ability to plan and carry out sensory and motor tasks. Generally, individuals with the disorder appear "out of sync" with their environment. Symptoms vary and may include poor balance and coordination, clumsiness, vision problems, perception difficulties, emotional and behavioral problems, difficulty with reading, writing, and speaking, poor social skills, poor posture, and poor short-term memory. Although individuals with the disorder may b
Read more

Battlestar Galactica needs more colour?

By
Here are the letters I mentioned in the previous post. The one that started it (I'm guessing these letters were written after the show's first airing at the end of 2003): Galactica Needs More Diversity The problem I had with Battlestar Galactica was there were no major and very few minor African American characters. There were no Black men in the show at all or if they were, they had virtually no screentime. In the original series, Boomer and Tigh were both played by African American actors. In this rendition of Battlestar, those characters were played by Asian and White actors. In the Caprica city, there no African American extras. On the Galactica's bridge, there was only one African American actress. Another Black actress could be found playing a religious official that swore in the new President of the colonies. This was very troubling to me. Do you not want African Americans to watch your show? Do you want to project the idea that African Americans are not part of the
Read more